As an independent insurance agency in New Holland and Lancaster, we work with a variety of regional and national insurance companies to find you the right policy for your needs.
Here are some of the insurance companies with whom we have a relationship:
Based in Erie, PA, Erie Insurance has been covering Pennsylvania individuals and families since 1925. Through Erie, we offer auto, home, life, and business insurance. Visit their website »
Donegal Insurance Group
For over 125 years, Donegal Insurance Group has provided property and casualty insurance throughout the Mid-Atlantic states. Based in Marietta, Lancaster County, Donegal offers coverage for auto, home, farm, and business. Visit their website »
Progressive is a national insurance company that specializes in auto and vehicle insurance. As an independent Progressive insurance agent, we offer coverage for auto, motorcycles, RV, and home. Visit their website »
Travelers is a national insurance company based in New York City. They bring over 160 years of experience to each policy, providing property casualty insurance for auto and home. Visit their website »
Motorists Mutual, part of the Motorists Insurance Group, is an insurance company serving most of the eastern United States. In addition to their automobile and RV insurance, Motorists Mutual offers property insurance, life insurance, and umbrella coverage. Visit their website »
Agency Insurance Company
Agency Insurance Company (AIC) is a regional auto insurance company serving residents of Maryland, Pennsylvania, and Delaware. They provide competitive rates on personal auto, commercial auto, motorcycle, and off-road vehicle insurance. Visit their website »
The oldest property insurance company in the country, Philadelphia Contributionship was founded by Ben Franklin in 1752. Now in their 266th year, this insurance company provides homeowners insurance, flood insurance, and umbrella liability insurance throughout Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Delaware, Maryland, and Virginia. Visit their website »
Reamstown Mutual Insurance Company
Based in nearby Reamstown, Lancaster County, the Reamstown Mutual Insurance Company has been providing insurance to our community for more than a century. They offer insurance targeted for homeowners, farmowners, and business owners, as well as policies for personal liability and umbrella. Visit their website »
Let Us Help You Choose
Unsure which insurance agency has the best premiums or coverage? Let us help. At Community Insurance, we shop these and other leading insurance companies to find the best insurance policy for you. Contact us to get a free quote on an insurance policy that’s tailored to you.
Get My Low Rate