Insurance Agency in New Holland, PA

Visit Our New Holland Office

Community Insurance office in New Holland PAHours: Monday-Friday: 8:30 am – 5:00 pm
Phone: (717) 354-4551
Fax: (717) 355-2154
684 West Main Street
New Holland, PA 17557
Get Directions »
Our New Holland, PA insurance agency is on New Holland Pike (Route 23). We are across the street from the New Holland Shopping Center, and next to the Sheetz on Shirk Road.

Serving the New Holland Community Since 1955

At Community Insurance, we are committed to be the best personal and business insurance agency in New Holland, PA. Whether you are looking for auto insurance, homeowner’s insurance, life insurance, or business insurance, we can find the right product for you. We’ll help you choose from Erie Insurance, Donegal Insurance Group, AIG, Motorist Mutual, Travelers, Progressive, and other A+ rated insurance companies, so you can receive the best rate and coverage for your needs. Plus, you’ll receive the attention, customer service, and options that is the hallmark of a local independent insurance agency.

From our New Holland office, we work with families and small businesses in Leola, East Earl, Blue Ball, Brownstown, Denver, Ephrata, Lititz, and the rest of Lancaster County. For our neighbors in western Lancaster County, you may find it more convenient visiting our Lancaster office.

We are an active part in our local community, supporting local charity events like the annual New Holland Golf Tournament hosted by the Kiwanis Club. We also partner with local businesses through our memberships in The Lancaster Chamber of Commerce & Industry and the New Holland Business Association.

What Our Clients Have to Say

Community Insurance is our preferred agency for business and personal insurance and we could not be more pleased with the service we have received. Deb in the New Holland office has been our go-to person and we appreciate her knowledge, professionalism, and sincere dedication to us. Importantly also, Community Insurance has shown its commitment to the community as a Major Sponsor of the annual Kiwanis of New Holland Golf Tournament which in turn supports local children’s charities and projects.

Vernon M.

I have working on our personal auto policy as well as getting my aunt established with Community Insurance. Blanche has been wonderful to work. She is very knowledgeable, helpful, patient and willing to take the time to help you understand the “ins and outs” of insurance. Would recommend them highly.

Colleen D. (Google Review)

Read more reviews »

New Holland Team



Thomas Mathison, CPCU, AU, CIC, API
Eric Schwenk



Deborah Groff, CIC


New Holland Staff

Michelle Scerbo
Colleen Matincheck
Customer Service Agent
Lisa Moser, CISR
Customer Service Agent
Blanche Nelson, CISR
Customer Service Agent
Christina Peterson, CISR
Customer Service Agent
Nichole Long
Nichole Long,
Customer Service Agent


New Holland Office – Customer Reviews

erie insurance logo
donegal insurance logo
progressive insurance logo
travelers insurance logo