Community Insurance
Your Local Independent Insurance Agency
Community insurance
Based in Lancaster and New Holland, we help individuals, families, nonprofits, and businesses across Pennsylvania and surrounding states find coverage that truly fits.
Built on Service, Rooted in Community
Community Insurance is a community-focused, independent insurance agency with offices in Lancaster and New Holland, PA. We combine decades of experience with neighborly service to help you protect your home, vehicles, business, and future with confidence. Because we’re independent, we can compare options from top carriers like Erie Insurance to match you with smart, affordable coverage instead of pushing a single company. Whether you found us by searching “community insurance,” “community insurance agency,” or even “community sure,” you’ll get the same local, personalized attention every time you call.
Farm & Agribusiness
Coverage designed for farms, agribusiness operations, and rural properties, helping protect buildings, equipment, livestock, liability, and your ability to keep working the land.
Commercial Auto
Policy options for work vehicles, service trucks, and fleets, plus protection for employees who drive on company business.
Non-profit Insurance
Specialized coverage for professionals and nonprofit organizations, including liability protection for advice, services, boards, and volunteers.
View All Commercial Insurance
Health Insurance
Guidance on individual, family, and single health insurance plans so you’re not navigating complex options alone.
Homeowners Insurance
Safeguard your home and belongings from fire, theft, storms, and everyday surprises, with coverage tailored to Lancaster city homes, suburbs, and rural properties.
Personal Auto Insurance
Protect your car, truck, or SUV with the right combination of liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage, plus discounts for safe drivers and multi-policy households.
View All Personal Insurance
Why Choose Community Insurance?
Why Clients Trust Community Insurance
An Independent Agency
As an independent agency, we’re free to act in your best interest—not a single company’s. That means we can compare coverage and pricing from multiple carriers to help you find the right balance of protection and value.
Truly Local
Our Lancaster and New Holland teams live and work in the same communities we serve, so we understand local roads, local weather, and local businesses. You’re never just a policy number here—you’re a neighbor we expect to see at the grocery store, ball field, or community event.
Top-Rated Carriers
We proudly represent top-rated carriers, including Erie Insurance, giving you access to strong coverage, competitive rates, and reliable claims service. When something goes wrong, we’re here to help you understand your options, advocate on your behalf, and get life back to normal as quickly as possible.
For many clients, Community Insurance becomes their long-term partner for community insurance solutions that grow as their lives and businesses evolve. Whether you need a single policy today or a full insurance review, we’re ready when you are.
Serving Lancaster County, Pennsylvania & Beyond
Our primary focus is serving individuals, families, and organizations in Lancaster County, including Lancaster, New Holland, York, and Harrisburg. From there, we extend coverage across Pennsylvania and into Delaware, Maryland, Virginia, and North Carolina, so your insurance can stay with you even when life takes you a little farther from home. As you grow—buying a home, starting a business, or expanding operations—we can help keep your protection aligned with your next chapter.
What Our Clients Are Saying
★★★★★
Real experiences from people we’ve helped
Very helpful. I was at work, and they understood, so we communicated via email. They worked with me base on coverage needs and how much I could afford. They answered my questions in a timely manner...very pleased with my experienced. And got coverages through a very respectful Insurance Company, Erie Insurance. Great job!
J. Torres
I have been working with Community Insurance for over 40 years through all their transitions. The staff (I have been through 2 agents who have retired) have always been helpful and professional. I have home owners, car, and business insurance with them. They are fantastic!!