Insurance Agency in Lancaster, PA

Visit our Lancaster, PA Office

Community Insurance Lancaster LocationHours: Monday-Friday: 8:30 am – 5:00 pm
Phone: (717) 397-7531
Fax: (717) 397-2296

101 Good Drive, 2nd Floor
Lancaster, PA 17603
Get Directions »
Our Lancaster, PA insurance agency is on Good Drive in Rohrerstown (East Hempfield Township). We are close to Rohrerstown Road (Route 741) and Columbia Avenue (Route 462).

Serving the Lancaster Community Since 1955

For over 60 years, Community Insurance has provided the best in personal and business insurance to the greater Lancaster County community. We provide a broad range of products for individuals, families, and small business owners, including auto insurance, homeowner’s insurance, life insurance, health insurance, and business insurance. As a locally-owned and operated independent insurance agency, we provide the customer service and attention that can be missing from larger agencies. Choose from Erie Insurance, Donegal Insurance Group, AIG, Motorist Mutual, Travelers, Progressive, and other highly rated insurance companies, so you can find the best rate and coverage for your insurance needs.

From our Lancaster office, we work with families and small businesses in Lititz, Manheim, Landisville, East Petersburg, Salunga, Mount Joy, Elizabethtown, Marietta, Columbia, Millersville, and the rest of western Lancaster County. For our neighbors in eastern Lancaster County, you may find it more convenient visiting our New Holland office.

As a member of The Lancaster Chamber of Commerce & Industry, we are able to collaborate with local businesses and charities to strengthen our community.

What Our Clients Have to Say

Community Insurance has served as a beacon of light, cutting through all the fog created throughout the ever changing healthcare reform. There has never been an occasion in which our concerns or questions were not answered or responded to in a timely fashion. As a non-profit corporation, I am quite confident that Community Insurance understands our insurance needs and work diligently to ensure these needs are met.
Chris Runkle – DARS, Inc.

The person I work had always been there every time I called. She is great with our car insurance, home owners insurance! She has helped when my son needed insurance. I was in an accident she was so helpful since it was my first time dealing with the situation. Great experience
Natalie B. (Google Review)

Read more reviews »

Lancaster Team



Thomas Mathison, CPCU, AU, CIC, API
Eric Schwenk



Terri Binkley, CISR
Commercial Lines Manager
Kelle Hertzog, CISR
Personal Lines Manager
Larry Snyder, CISR
IT Manager


Lancaster Staff

Paul Black
Producer / Licensed Agent
Jeff Smith
Producer / Licensed Agent
Domenick Rose
Domenick Rose, LUTCF
Life Producer


Personal Lines Service / Sales

Brenda Beck, CISR
Customer Service Agent
Kathy Davis, CISR
Customer Service Agent
Susie Ketner, CISR
Customer Service Agent


Linda Raffensberger, CISR
Customer Service Agent
Amy Gundrum, CISR
Customer Service Agent


Commercial Lines Service / Sales

Donna Findley, CISR
Customer Service Agent
Joanne Kinch
Customer Service Agent


Jennifer Hershey
Administrative Assistant
Sonia Ruiz
Administrative Assistant


Lancaster Office – Customer Reviews

erie insurance logo
donegal insurance logo
progressive insurance logo
travelers insurance logo